Sunday Salon – Review of “City of Thieves” by David Benioff

The Sunday Salon.com

Note 1: This book is reviewed by my husband Jim.

Note 2: Caution! Some spoilers in this review.

This is not the ultimate coming of age novel, but it is a coming of age story in ultimate circumstances — Leningrad in 1942, which at that time was under siege by the Nazis, experienced frequent bombardment, had little or no food, and was under oppressive surveillance by the NKVD. [The NKVD was the name for the Soviet Secret Police before it was changed to the KGB.]

“The Siege of Leningrad” began in September, 1941. When German forces reached Leningrad, Hitler demanded that the city be cut off from food and supplies and razed to the ground. For almost 900 days, the Germans laid siege to the city as hundreds of thousands of residents died.

The protagonist, 17-year-old Lev Beniov, is a diffident, colorless boy who is arrested for curfew violation and theft of government property (a capital offense in 1942 Leningrad). While in prison he comes under the influence of a crafty accused deserter (Kolya) who becomes his best friend. Improbably, Lev and Kolya are released by an NKVD colonel who wants them to find eggs for his daughter’s wedding cake.

Stealing eggs during the Siege of Leningrad turns out to more than a simple search for hens. The boys must penetrate the Nazi lines, for there is no food to be found in the Russian countryside. In the process, Lev meets an NKVD sniper (Vika) who later becomes his wife; is captured and nearly executed; participates in a bizarre chess game for his life; kills two Germans (including an Einsatzgruppe colonel) with a knife; and sees Kolya killed by friendly fire. Coming of age was eventful on the Eastern Front.

The book is well written, fast paced, and loaded with irony. Lev is captured by the NKVD only because he stops to help one of his friends (a girl on whom he has a crush, but who hardly notices him) climb a fence. He goes to prison on the night his apartment building (where the girl lives) is destroyed in a Nazi bombardment. Kolya talks his way out of numerous impossible situations only to be shot by Russian troops when he tries to return to Leningrad. Lev overcomes insuperable obstacles to obtain a dozen eggs for the wedding cake, only to learn that an airlift of supplies has just gotten through, and the NKVD colonel already has three dozen eggs for the cake.

The narrator and principal character, Lev, is complex and vulnerable. The two colonels (Nazi and NKVD) are minatory, but have wry senses of humor. Kolya and Vika are a little too competent to be believable, but will make popular characters in the inevitable screen play.

The setting for the narration of the book is artfully contrived. In the unnumbered preface, the author (David Benioff) asks his grandfather (Lev Beniov) to tell him about Leningrad during the war. Grandfather agrees to talk, but forgets the details. The author prods him to remember because “a couple of things don’t make sense.” Grandfather retorts, “You’re a writer. Make it up.”

Rating: 4/5

Published by Viking / Penguin, 2008

About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review, Sunday Salon and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Sunday Salon – Review of “City of Thieves” by David Benioff

  1. nymeth says:

    I actually think that’s a pretty interesting way to frame a story! I love the sound of this – adding it to my list.

  2. Sandy says:

    What a bizarre premise! I’ve read a couple of reviews of this book, and I’ve been intrigued. I like that time period first of all. Just about anything that occurs during that time is instantly more fascinating.

  3. bermudaonion says:

    This sounds so good. I was going to add it to my wish list and noticed it’s already there. I guess I need to get hold of this book.

  4. I just added this to my gotta read it list. Thanks for your terrific review.
    I loved this:
    The author prods him to remember because “a couple of things don’t make sense.” Grandfather retorts, “You’re a writer. Make it up.”

  5. Lisa says:

    Thanks for the review, Jim. I loved this book. The details about life in Leningrad were incredible and I really liked the friendship between Kolya and Lev.

  6. Jenny says:

    Thanks for the review! I’ve heard good things about this book before and keep forgetting to add it to my list.

  7. Amused says:

    I just got this book and am so looking forward to reading it. Glad to hear you liked it. Your review makes it sound great!

  8. Sounds like a book that my dad would enjoy. Thanks for the great guest review!

  9. stacybuckeye says:

    Great husband review! I think my own hubby would like this one!
    I love the author and his grandfather story 🙂

  10. Staci says:

    Loved your perspective of this book. I enjoyed it immensely last year!!

  11. Bookjourney says:

    This sounds interesting. Good review Jim!

  12. Marie says:

    I loved this book! The ending- the very end- was especially wonderful.

  13. Gayle says:

    Thanks for this review. I have had this book for a while and haven’t been that tempted to read it – glad you liked it. Will move it up the list!

  14. Ruth says:

    I too found this account compelling, and am trying to remember the name of a work of fiction from the same period, from the perspective of a woman who had helped remove art treasures from the Hermitage. I read it, but can’t remember title or author. Can anyone help?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.