Sunday Treat – National Poetry Month – The Graphic Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock

sundae2How wonderful that my very favorite poem, “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” by T.S. Eliot, is now out in a comic-book adaptation by Julian Peters. I have posted about this poem several times, including one in which I embedded a lovely video of Michael Gough performing the poem.

Poetry resembles performing art, but also visual art; it is to a great extent the result of turning words into images. Thus it is fitting that someone should turn that idea around, and render poems as graphic art. Peters has done an excellent job. I especially love the the box for the line “Do I dare disturb the universe?”


You can see more sample pages here.


To celebrate National Poetry Month, Serena from Savvy Verse and Wit has called on fellow bloggers to participate by profiling a poet or poem. Be sure to stop by Serena’s blog every day this month to see more profiles of poets and poetry by participants from around the blogisphere!

National Poetry Month Kid Lit Review of “A Dance Like Starlight: One Ballerina’s Dream” by Kristy Dempsey


While this book is not strictly categorized as “poetry,” the author is a poet, and the text of this book reads like free verse, as with this description of a ballet performance:

When she glides onto the stage,
I don’t know
if I am dreaming,
if I am even breathing,
because she doesn’t seem to touch the floor.
She twirls and
my heart jumps up from where I’m sitting,
soaring, dancing,
opening wide with the swell of the music.”

The story is narrated by a fictional young African American girl in New York in the 1950′s who dreams of becoming a prima ballerina. Her mother cleans and sews costumes for a ballet school, and the little girl dances in the wings as she waits for Mama. The Ballet Master lets her join lessons from the back of the room, but she is not allowed to perform on the stage with white girls.


One day she catches bits of a story in a newspaper about Janet Collins: “first colored prima ballerina… Metropolitan Opera House.”


Mama uses half the money she saved for a new sewing machine to take her daughter to see Janet Collins perform, and they are both inspired:

Mama and I dance our way home
under the night sky,
and I don’t even try
to catch a glimpse of the first star.
no need to waste my wishes.
I’ve got dreams coming true.”

The award-winning illustrator, Floyd Cooper, known for his use of warm tones and historical accuracy, is the perfect choice for this story. His technique of “subtraction” to erase shapes from a background of paint, softens the pictures and gives them a gauzy quality, adding to the sense that this is a story from the past.


Discussion: Before you get to the Author’s Note at the conclusion of the book about who Janet Collins was and when she danced, there is no indication this story takes place in the early 1950’s. The Note provides brief background information on Ms. Collins, born in 1917 in Louisiana, who became the first African American to be hired full-time by the Metropolitan Opera in New York, initially performing in November, 1951.

Ms. Collins experienced a great deal of resistance in her attempts to perform in professional classical dance troupes. In 1932, for example, she was asked to join the prestigious Ballet Russe de Monte Carlo, but she would have been required to paint her face and skin white to appear on stage. She turned down the offer. She was also not allowed to be on tour with the rest of her ballet company in parts of the Deep South. She retired in her forties and joined a Benedictine community.

Janet Collins

Janet Collins

The poetic prose is quite nice, and Cooper’s illustrations are lovely as usual, but I think it would help understanding of the story to know at the outset that it takes place in an earlier time.

Evaluation: Any story is enhanced by the outstanding artwork of Floyd Cooper, and the integration of ballet is a topic not often covered by other books.

Rating: 3.5/5

Published by Philomel Books, an imprint of Penguin Young Readers Group, 2014

Review of “Dog Gone, Back Soon” by Nick Trout

This is an adorable story about Cyrus Mills, a veterinarian in his late thirties who returns to northern Vermont after his father’s death to run his father’s veterinary practice, The Bedside Manor for Sick Animals.


There’s a subplot about the Evil Corporate Competitor, a national chain called Healthy Paws, and one involving Cyrus’s romantic interest in a local waitress named Amy Carp (presumably a hat tip to the author, Nick Trout). But the real appeal of the book is the wonderful collection of anecdotes about pets.

Evaluation: This is apparently a sequel to The Patron Saint of Lost Dog. I did not read this book, and thought the author did a fair (but not excellent) job of filling in new readers, mostly about how Cyrus got interested in Amy. But it didn’t really matter much. The book has loads of humor, charm, and great pet stories by a guy who knows what he is talking about. The author is a graduate of the veterinary school at the University of Cambridge, a Diplomate of the American and European Colleges of Veterinary Surgeons , and a staff surgeon at Angell Animal Medical Center in Boston. If you love pets, you’ll love this book!

Rating: 3.5/5

Published by Hyperion, a division of Hachette Book Group, Inc., 2014

Review of “Ancillary Justice” by Ann Leckie

This book, set way, way far in the future, is very complicated and very out-of-the-box. The story, a mystery/thriller, employs some stunning premises. One is that some of the characters, including the main protagonist, are massive entities with hive-minds that reside in multiple bodies at once. The second is that, in this future galaxy, gender is maybe a matter of choice, or maybe of convenience; it’s unclear. All we know is that we don’t know what gender anyone is, but everyone is universally designated as “she.” This creates some eye-opening confusion for the reader, revealing, by that very confusion, just how much we attribute to, and assume by, gender designations in our own world.


As the story begins, Breq (whose name might well have been Brusque) has occupied a single body for nineteen years. Before that, he/she was the troop carrier Justice of Toren in the Radch Empire, with a number of “ancillaries,” or mobile units on detached duty down on a planet’s surface. (An ancillary is created by adding artificial intelligence to a captured human body.) The individual we meet as “Breq” was formerly the ancillary One Esk, but because Breq occupies only one body now, he/she can pass for “human.”

Breq is on an obsessive and seemingly impossible mission to kill the Lord of the Radch Empire, and we learn why in chapters that alternate between Breq’s existence as Justice of Toren nineteen years ago, and life now as a single individual. As the story unfolds, the tension ratchets up, and the book becomes “easier” as well, with the gaining of greater understanding into some of the complex aspects of this universe.

Discussion: A major theme of this book is a problem we have even in our present day, which is what role citizens should assume in the face of immoral laws. If a law violates all that we consider to be worthwhile and just in the human community, must we still obey? Are we culpable if we do? What if the result of disobedience is death? Is it an excuse to say “I didn’t have a choice?” What would “justice” mean under those circumstances?

Secondly, but in a related way, there is the issue of imperialism. Is one nation (or planet) really qualified to determine what constitutes “civilization” for the other, and to enforce its own ideas over those of the natives? Again, these are problems we have grappled with in our own time, and readers will find it thought-provoking to read the opinions bandied about in political wrangling in this future galaxy.

There are some appealing secondary characters (all human) who accompany Breq on the journey past and future, including Captain Seivardan Vendaai, Lieutenant Awn Elming, and Lieutenant Skaaiat Awer. Are they male or female? I have no idea, but it was revelatory to see my own preconceptions unfold as I unconsciously assigned a gender to them based on their behaviors. In any event, they are all incredibly nuanced and interesting.

Evaluation: This story is very demanding; the universe of this far away future is very different than ours, and it takes a bit of mental work not to feel disoriented. Nevertheless, if you like having your conceptual framework taken out for examination from time to time, and if you enjoy suspense and science fiction, this book is worth the effort.

Rating: 3.5/5

Published by Orbit, an imprint of Hachette Book Group, Inc., 2013

Review of “Windfallen” by Jojo Moyes

Having discovered that I loved the writing of Jojo Moyes, I’ve set about to read through her backlist. Windfallen is her second novel, and was originally published in the UK as Foreign Fruit, which, to my thinking, is a much more appropriate title.

Screen Shot 2013-11-18 at 11.56.28 AM

The novel begins in the 1950’s in the conservative seaside town of Merham a couple of hours from London. The community is appalled when a previously empty 1930’s art deco house known as Arcadia is taken over by a group of bohemians with ambigious domestic relationships. But 18-year-olds Celia Holden and her friend Lottie Swift (who lives with Celia’s family), are bedazzled. They are fit to burst from the constricting binds of Celia’s uptight mother and Merham’s equally uptight fear of change. They begin to visit the newcomers, entranced by the exotic way they live and their lack of inhibitions. Celia’s mother finds out and sends her off to London. Eight weeks later Celia returns with a fiancé, Guy Bancroft. But everything becomes upended, and Lottie is forced to leave town.

Fifty years later, we pick up with the story of Daisy Parsons, an interior designer who has been hired to restore Arcadia as a hotel. Daisy, 28, has just been abandoned by the father of her four-month old daughter, but needs to pull herself together and complete this job in order to turn her life around. As she uncovers the secrets of Arcadia, she not only helps bring change to Merham, but discovers her own destiny in the process.

Evaluation: Jojo Moyes is an excellent and engrossing storyteller, and of course she had me sobbing by three-quarters of the way through the book. If you like sagas about lost love and found love with a well-written historical background, this will definitely appeal to you. I suppose it is properly considered a “romance,” and in fact it won the 2004 Romance Novelist Association (RNA) Book of the Year Award (under its British title, Foreign Fruit). But I would certainly class Jojo Moyes head and shoulders above many writers designated by that genre.

Rating: 4/5

Published in the UK as Foreign Fruit by Hodder & Stoughton, 2003; Published in the U.S. as Windfallen by William Morrow, an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers, hardcover 2003; paperback 2013.

Celebrate National Library Week!

This year National Library Week is from April 13 to April 19th, and the 2014 theme is:

Lives change @ your library

Specific days during this week are reserved to honor different aspects of libraries; be sure to stop in at your library tomorrow to celebrate National Library Workers Day! If you haven’t seen one of my favorite movies ever, Party Girl with Parker Posey, this scene will give you a sense of what library workers must endure every day!

Happy Library Week!!

1969 Poster by Peter Max for National Library Week

1969 Poster by Peter Max for National Library Week

April 13, 1743 – Birthdate (Sort Of) Of Thomas Jefferson and Review of “Thomas Jefferson: Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Everything” by Maira Kalman

Thomas Jefferson, one of the Founding Fathers of America, was born on April 2 according to the old style (Julian) calendar, which was changed in 1752 in the U.S. to the Gregorian calendar, still in use today. The new calendar pushed all dates forward by eleven days, so that Jefferson’s birthdate became April 13. Those born during this period often celebrated their birthdays on both days, if they celebrated at all. (According to scholars at Monticello, Jefferson always insisted the only birthday he observed was July 4, the birthday of his country.)


Maira Kalman creates gorgeous books, and fortunately, she is an excellent storyteller as well. Her book for children on the life of Lincoln was absolutely wonderful (see my review here) but I was worried about this one: what would she say about Jefferson and his unwillingness to give up his slaves?

Kalman does not make Jefferson’s weaknesses central to the book, but she doesn’t ignore them either. She writes:

‘The man who said of slavery ‘This ABOMINATION MUST END’ was the ownere of about 150 slaves. The MONUMENTAL MAN had MONUMENTAL FLAWS.”

Including a reproduction of the list of Jefferson’s slaves in his farm books, she notes:

OUR hearts are BROKEN.”

Screen Shot 2014-01-26 at 11.38.17 AM

Most of all, however, Kalman focuses on Jefferson’s eclectic range of interests, his love of books – “on history, science, philosophy, government, mathematics, music, art and so much more”), his work on his estate which he called Monticello, and his accomplishments in government.


She explains about his belief in the separation of church and state, and about his purchase from Napoleon of a large part of the land that became the United States.

She ends with the advice:

If you want to understand this country and its people and what it means to be optimistic and complex and tragic and wrong and courageous, you need to go to Monticello.”

What an amazingly concise and astute way to summarize not just the character of Jefferson, but of the other Founding Fathers as well.

Screen Shot 2014-04-06 at 4.06.10 PM

The Matisse-like whimsical paintings in the book are bursting with vibrant colors, and the typeface varies in size, style, and color, depending on the text.


In the back, a brief annotated note section adds more details about the people and events described in the book.

Evaluation: This is an outstanding resource about Jefferson for readers of all ages. The text is funny and informative, with lots of kid appeal. The illustrations are stunning.

Rating: 5/5

Published by Nancy Paulsen Books, an imprint of Penguin Group (USA) Inc., 2014.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 282 other followers