Review of “I’ll Give You the Sun” by Jandy Nelson

This outstanding book just blew me away. It’s about a set of fraternal twins, a boy Noah and a girl Jude, who take turns narrating the story. And it’s about the power of art to inform perspective, not just in a medium, but as a medium, as a way of interpreting the world. And in fact, Noah and Jude’s parents grow apart as their epistemology diverges: their dad, a doctor, is wedded to the empirical while their mom embraces the spiritual, and all its messy glorious manifestation in color and form.


Jude and Noah have always been so close that they feel like they are only half-people when apart; together, they make up one complete and whole person. But at age thirteen, as the two prepare to apply for a special school for the arts, there are radical changes in their lives, and by the time they are sixteen, they barely speak to one another. Noah’s chapters are from the time they are thirteen, and Jude’s from when they are sixteen. But they carry the action forward linearly, nevertheless. And as the story progresses, all the secrets about the lives of the characters gradually come to light.

Discussion: There are a number of love stories that go on simultaneously in this book, focused on several different kinds of love. They are all brimming with intense emotion and hope and hurt and surprise, and range from the split-apart whole of the twins to the idea of soulmates who are split apart by the gods, and spend their lives looking for each other. Only the luckiest humans succeed in finding them.

There are also interconnected themes about being true to one’s soul; the wisdom or folly of showing that inner spirit to someone else; and the way a portrait artist can reveal someone’s inner self by studying someone enough to see it. It is only then that the face comes alive, and no matter how simple or few the lines, no matter how “realistic” or “impressionistic,” people can recognize the essence of the person in the picture.

My favorite picture by Picasso:  it is not complex or intricate, but you *know* this guy from looking at his portrait

My favorite picture by Picasso: it is not complex or intricate, but you *know* this guy from looking at his portrait

Noah, who has a wonderful self-deprecating sense of humor, describes many of his experiences by what a portrait of someone would look like at any particular moment: “Self-Portrait: The Boy Hiding Inside the Boy Hiding Inside the Boy”; “Portrait: Mom and Dad with Screeching Tea Kettles for Heads”; “Portrait: Jude Braiding Boy After Boy into Her Hair”.”

Jude, on the other hand, exposes her innermost thoughts by conversations with her dead grandmother, and by spouting quotations from the sayings her grandmother collected in her bible. Jude is also very funny in a different way than Noah, using superstition to try to control reality, because a more reason-based approach hasn’t been working out so well.

Evaluation: I could go on and on about the many wonderful aspects of this book, but I would hate to give it all away. Though the subjects covered in this book are heavy ones: death, grief, betrayal, homosexuality, jealousy, and fractured family dynamics – at the same time, this is a book of soaring positive emotions: passion, love, friendship, and forgiveness; all drawn (in a double sense) with talent, humor and compassion. I went through almost a whole packet of stickies marking passages I wanted to remember, including some that took my breathe away with their unexpectedness or cleverness or insight. Highly recommended!

Rating: 5/5

Published by Dial Books, an imprint of Penguin Group (USA), 2014

Note: This book won the prestigious 2015 Printz Award.

About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to Review of “I’ll Give You the Sun” by Jandy Nelson

  1. I can’t wait to get my hands on this. It isn’t out in the UK yet, so I have a few months to wait. It sounds amazing.

  2. Beth F says:

    Ok so I didn’t need to read beyond “This outstanding book just blew me away. It’s about a set of fraternal twins.” I have this on the pile … hoping to read soon, soon, soon.

  3. Kailana says:

    I have been seeing this book around but you might actually be my first review of it. I will have to add it to the wish list. 🙂

  4. I need to read this – it was on my TBR list from last year and I never got to it.

  5. BermudaOnion says:

    It sounds like this won the Printz Award for good reason. I need to pick it up!

  6. Adding this to my list – immediately!

  7. Ti says:

    Is it book club worthy?

    • That’s a complicated question. I tend to like books for book clubs that are controversial and/or full of moral conundrums. I remember when my book club read Cutting for Stone, and everyone loved it, so no one had anything to say! I think it’s possible that could be the fate of this book too.

  8. OOH the fact that you said it blew you away has my attention!

  9. Belle Wong says:

    Since it blew you away … I’ll definitely have to keep my eye out for it.

  10. sandynawrot says:

    Whoa, whoa, whoa! FIVE STARS? Well I guess that pretty much settles it for me.

  11. Anita says:

    I have this book, need to find time to read it, some other friends said I’d love it. Loved your review.

  12. Heather says:

    So yeah I’m with Sandy … any five-star rating you give out equals a must-read for me.

  13. stacybuckeye says:

    Okay, like a few others have said before, 5 stars from you means I need to take a look. Twins have always fascinated me so I was already interested before your gushing 🙂

  14. And here I had decided not to read this! (Nothing against Jandy Nelson — just because since YA is a genre where it’s often easier to find books by people of color, I’ve tapered way off on reading YA books by white folks.) But you’re making the alternating viewpoints sound reeeeally good.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.