Review of “The Paying Guests” by Sarah Waters

Note: There are no spoilers in this review.

Waters once again explores gender and class in a historical context, this time in the early years of post-World War I London.

With the men in their family having died in the war, Frances Wray (at 26, considered a “spinster”) and her mother have been forced to take in boarders in their large house for extra income. A young insurance clerk, Len Barber, and his bohemian wife Lilian come to stay in the house. Frances quickly discerns that the Barbers’ marriage isn’t a happy one. She becomes friends with Lilian, eventually confiding to her that she is attracted to women rather than to men. Frances becomes more and more obsessed with Lilian, and in a short time, Lilian seems to reciprocate. But what will they do about Frances’s mother and Lilian’s husband?

the paying guests - sarah waters

Discussion: Waters is so good at capturing the nuances of gender roles and expectations, and of their application to relationships between two people of the same sex. She is also expert at conveying the bizarre and infuriating class conventions that were especially salient in earlier times. But in this book, I feel she goes too far, or rather, goes on for too long. In portraying the tedium of Frances’s life, for example, she takes us through the same mind-numbing routines day after day. Couldn’t she just show us one typical day? Similarly, she is so skilled at showing us the anxieties of the characters and their moral equivocating, but must we hear about it over and over? I don’t think any of the carefully established moods of the story would have been lost by some editing.

The second problem I had was that I just could not like any of the characters, with the possible exception of Lilian’s mother. Frances’ mother is well-drawn, but so petulant and controlling as to make occupying even the same fictional room with her a very unpleasant experience. Len Barber is repulsive in every aspect. Lilian and Frances are both weak and vacillating; perhaps a willingness to have a sapphic relationship is “brave” but in every other respect they seem to me to lack conviction.

In the second half of the novel the action takes a disturbing turn. The protagonists have a whole new reality with which to cope, and we readers must endure every twist and turn of their thinking. Yes, it’s masterfully done, but again, it’s done for too long. And I, for one, found the ending profoundly unsatisfying.

Rating: 3/5

Published by Riverhead Books, a member of Penguin Group (USA), 2014


About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Review of “The Paying Guests” by Sarah Waters

  1. sandynawrot says:

    That is so disappointing, but I will read this one anyway. I have a soft spot for Waters, even with all her literary foibles. So many people had issues with The Little Stranger but I adored it. I’m hoping to start this one soon!

  2. diane says:

    It was a tad long, but I just really got into this one and loved it all.

  3. BermudaOnion says:

    I was excited about this book because I’ve heard so much about Waters’ work. I have become very impatient with books that are too long so I’ll probably put off reading this one.

  4. I still need to read The Little Stranger… guess I’ll save this for later.

  5. Huh! I absolutely loved this — maybe my expectations were low after I struggled some with The Little Stranger. I don’t know that I necessarily loved all of the characters, but I thought each one had interesting and (in most cases) admirable qualities. And I thought Waters did such a great job delineating the small emotional moments between the characters.

  6. Ti says:

    I got an early copy from the library but they didn’t send me a Kindle version. They sent me an epub version which is useless to me. Then I got it an audio through Overdrive but the file was corrupted and Overdrive could not fix it. So, I never did get to it and with your 3 rating, now I am not so anxious.

  7. jilllora says:

    I loved her earlier books, but found Little Stranger to be a big let down, so I’m hesitant to even try this one.

  8. Beth F says:

    Hummm, maybe I’ll wait a little while for this. I’m falling behind on books because, well, there are so many good choices out there.

  9. melreadingcorner says:

    I’m currently reading the second part of this book. I can see there’s a slight turn of events and can’t wait to find out what it is.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.