Review of “Snapshot: A Jamieson Brothers Novel” by Angie Stanton

This is the story of Marti Hunter, who is attending a small arts camp in Northern Wisconsin for teens to immerse herself in photography. Adam Jamieson is also attending for the same reason. He has cut off his hair and is going by the name “AJ” so no one will know he is the famous rock guitarist in his band of brothers; he just wants to have a normal experience for once.

14759416

Marti is herself the daughter of a famous rock guitarist from the band Graphite Angels. But her dad is an irresponsible louche and her mother is an addict. She lives with her Grandma.

At the camp, all the kids attending become Insta-BFFs. Some even pair up. Marti and AJ are attracted to one another until Marti finds out that AJ is really Adam. Because of her dad, she has a very bad opinion of rocker guitarists.

So they have a love – then hate – then love thing going on, culminating in a first sexual encounter for both of them. But extenuating circumstances cause both Marti and AJ to have to leave camp ahead of schedule, and they wonder if they will ever see each other again (when not wondering if Marti could be pregnant).

Discussion: This is one of several books in a series concerning a boy band and the girls with whom the members get involved. My niece turned 14 in June and she loves these books, so I wanted to read at least one in order to see what was floating her boat. The two main protagonists are 16. They and all their friends are gorgeous, relatively prosperous, and white. They think stilted thoughts and have hackneyed dialogue.

“AJ’s friendly demeanor made her feel like she’d known him forever.”

“The sun kissed his hair with blond highlights, and a bronze tan covered his body.”

“When their lips parted to take a breath, Adam’s eyes turned dark with little flecks of gold passion sparkling in their brown depths.”

Guys who think about their girlfriends or show them consideration are “whipped.”

There is also the usual stereotypical image of the strong yet gentle boy, and the appealingly smaller and protection-needing girl:

“As the sound faded, Marti stayed in AJ’s secure arms a few seconds longer. He had strong arms and a solid chest, as if he could protect a girl from anything.

“He held her gently and she began to cry. … Her tiny body shook as the tears fell.”

Kind of a horrifying image, isn’t it? It is also illustrative of the point I was making in a recent post about the deleterious nature of male-driven notions of eroticism that characterize even books written by women.

As noted above, Adam and Marti, barely out of pre-school (at least from my adult perspective) quickly graduate to having sex. Unprotected even. Holy cow! But they do “learn” from this and vow never to do such a thing again, that is, without taking precautions.

I send my niece Rainbow Rowell. I send her John Green. I send her Maggie Stiefvater. But she prefers these books by Angie Stanton. But you know what, I get it. When I was that age, there was nothing that filled my head more than dreams of meeting up with the latest rock star and having him discover out of all the people in the universe, **I** was his dream girl. Weird. Must be genetic. (However, I did not include sex in my fantasies. I didn’t even know about such a thing! These kids today!)

Evaluation: The idea of a romance with a member of a boy band will be very appealing to at least some tween readers.

Rating: 3/5

Note: This is number two in the series, but it reads like a standalone.

Published by Harper Teen, an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers, 2013

Advertisements

About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Review of “Snapshot: A Jamieson Brothers Novel” by Angie Stanton

  1. sandynawrot says:

    OK so I will officially comment, even though we discussed offline. I really worry about books like this, that all the tween and early teen girls flock to. The acceptability of sex at that age, and that it is romantic. Luckily, my daughter’s Honors and AP lit classes have kept her busy with more worthy stuff!

  2. I can’t see myself ever reading these and I have boys, so they wouldn’t either. But, I love, love, love your review. “They think stilted thoughts and have hackneyed dialogue.” Love it!

  3. Ick. And with the unprotected sex as well? Ick.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s