Review of “The Painter” by Peter Heller

Jim Stegner, 45, is a bereaved father who manages the loss of his daughter by externalizing his emotions, whether through drinking, painting, fishing, or violence. He is trying hard to understand his weight in the world: his effect, his responsibility, his capacity for endurance. He thinks he means well, and we tend to accept his arguments, and yet, death and destruction follow in his wake. Jim’s violent acts are always “justified” in some ways, since Jim repeatedly finds himself taking the role of vigilante against truly evil people. But as one of the supporting characters points out, “Jim… you know, we can’t just go around killing each other. Just saying.”


He doesn’t understand his choices himself:

“I never imagined I would shoot a man. Or be a father. Or live so far from the sea. As a child, you imagine your life sometimes, how it will be. I never thought I would be a painter. That I might make a world and walk into it and forget myself. That art would be something I would not have any way of not doing.”

He blames himself for the consequences of what he does, even if his reactions were provoked or in self-defense, and he can’t shake the pain of it. Nor can he stop himself.

He expresses his tortured psyche through his art, and he has gained some renown as “a Great American Southwest Post-Expressionist Naif.” The darker his life gets, the better and closer to “truth” is his art, but that isn’t what drives him. He can no more curb the drive to visualize his interior mind than he can resist the urge to inhabit his sorrow. Because if he openly confronts his anguish, could he even bear it? And if he overcomes the sadness and the loss of his daughter, wouldn’t he lose her entirely?

Discussion: Although Jim is a shattered man, somewhere within him there is a strong pull toward hope as well as decency. He also has a profound appreciation of the land and its creatures, even as its beauty is constantly juxtaposed with the brutal ugliness of some of the people he encounters. His elegantly phrased observations portray “truth” as surely as his paintings must, admirably employing poetic construction in place of metaphor:

“The afternoon is somber under cloud, then the edge tugs away and the water sparks in a sudden sweep of sunlight.”

“Out the open double doors the mountain was catching the full brunt of the lowering sun. Every outcrop and rockslide, the quilt of the forests: spruce and aspen, juniper, oak, lit to sharper detail and warmed by the obeyed light. Sharpened and softened at the same time.”

But when he does use metaphor, it is exceptionally well done, as in this passage in which he succinctly captures not only his sense of the slowness of the passing of time, but the menace of the dangerous situation in which he finds himself:

“What time was it? Would this day ever end? Time did that thing it does, when it uncurls and lengthens like a rattlesnake patiently sliding after a mouse.”

In some ways the writing may be too pretty – too much a focus on the medium can fend off intimacy. I didn’t connect as well with the pain of the protagonist as I might have – but then again, Jim himself was loathe to face his pain, only able to channel it into painting, or blot it out with drinking or fishing.

The action in this book moves from Colorado to New Mexico, and for evoking a sense of place and distilling a mood, few can match this poetic author.

Evaluation: Heller makes meditative heroes unforgettable through often resplendent prose, and thought-provoking themes. I would follow this author anywhere.

Note: This haunting story with its prismatic treatment of moral ambiguity and the nature of justice would be an excellent choice for book clubs.

Rating: 4/5

Published by Alfred A. Knopf, 2014


About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Review of “The Painter” by Peter Heller

  1. ryandejonghe says:

    Great review. That opening is one of my favorites out of my recent readings.

  2. diane says:

    This sounds like one I’d enjoy as well –can’t wait to try it. Thanks for sharing Jill.

  3. Hadn’t heard of this title, but think I might like it… and it does sound like a good book club selection, too! Thanks, Jill.

  4. BermudaOnion says:

    Hm, I’ve got this on audio and I wonder if the pretty writing style will work for me that way.

  5. Athira says:

    This does sound like something I would enjoy. Pretty writing works for me. I don’t know yet how too much of it will work, but we’ll see.

  6. Ti says:

    Oh good. I know we both enjoyed his other book so now I am looking forward to this one.

  7. sandynawrot says:

    Hmmm. Intrigue. That’s some great writing.

  8. trish422 says:

    What a fascinating premise, and the excerpt suggests some pretty awesome writing.

  9. Beth F says:

    This is my favorite book of the year. I LOVED this book. No such thing as too pretty.

  10. stacybuckeye says:

    “Jim… you know, we can’t just go around killing each other. Just saying.”
    Made me laugh and think I would like it and that was before I read the rest. Great writing!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.