Review of “Ancillary Justice” by Ann Leckie

This book, set way, way far in the future, is very complicated and very out-of-the-box. The story, a mystery/thriller, employs some stunning premises. One is that some of the characters, including the main protagonist, are massive entities with hive-minds that reside in multiple bodies at once. The second is that, in this future galaxy, gender is maybe a matter of choice, or maybe of convenience; it’s unclear. All we know is that we don’t know what gender anyone is, but everyone is universally designated as “she.” This creates some eye-opening confusion for the reader, revealing, by that very confusion, just how much we attribute to, and assume by, gender designations in our own world.

9780316246620_custom-1b8a3367be3348eb1c36a41bd0e8c2563decdbfa-s2-c85

As the story begins, Breq (whose name might well have been Brusque) has occupied a single body for nineteen years. Before that, he/she was the troop carrier Justice of Toren in the Radch Empire, with a number of “ancillaries,” or mobile units on detached duty down on a planet’s surface. (An ancillary is created by adding artificial intelligence to a captured human body.) The individual we meet as “Breq” was formerly the ancillary One Esk, but because Breq occupies only one body now, he/she can pass for “human.”

Breq is on an obsessive and seemingly impossible mission to kill the Lord of the Radch Empire, and we learn why in chapters that alternate between Breq’s existence as Justice of Toren nineteen years ago, and life now as a single individual. As the story unfolds, the tension ratchets up, and the book becomes “easier” as well, with the gaining of greater understanding into some of the complex aspects of this universe.

Discussion: A major theme of this book is a problem we have even in our present day, which is what role citizens should assume in the face of immoral laws. If a law violates all that we consider to be worthwhile and just in the human community, must we still obey? Are we culpable if we do? What if the result of disobedience is death? Is it an excuse to say “I didn’t have a choice?” What would “justice” mean under those circumstances?

Secondly, but in a related way, there is the issue of imperialism. Is one nation (or planet) really qualified to determine what constitutes “civilization” for the other, and to enforce its own ideas over those of the natives? Again, these are problems we have grappled with in our own time, and readers will find it thought-provoking to read the opinions bandied about in political wrangling in this future galaxy.

There are some appealing secondary characters (all human) who accompany Breq on the journey past and future, including Captain Seivardan Vendaai, Lieutenant Awn Elming, and Lieutenant Skaaiat Awer. Are they male or female? I have no idea, but it was revelatory to see my own preconceptions unfold as I unconsciously assigned a gender to them based on their behaviors. In any event, they are all incredibly nuanced and interesting.

Evaluation: This story is very demanding; the universe of this far away future is very different than ours, and it takes a bit of mental work not to feel disoriented. Nevertheless, if you like having your conceptual framework taken out for examination from time to time, and if you enjoy suspense and science fiction, this book is worth the effort.

Rating: 3.5/5

Published by Orbit, an imprint of Hachette Book Group, Inc., 2013

Advertisement

About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Review of “Ancillary Justice” by Ann Leckie

  1. sandynawrot says:

    Well first I feel compelled to say that the cover is bad. It does not entice me to read it! The premise is clever and seems thought-provoking, but I can tell you right now that if I am required any more than keeping my eyes open, I’m not going to get it read. I am facing a four hour car ride this morning, so we’ll see how much I get done.

  2. This was one of those sci-fi books that critics just loved, and it’s gotten nominated for so many awards…. but I really didn’t like it at all. In fact, the more distance I get from it, the less I like it. The most interesting aspect of it was the exploration of gender perception/issues. The plot was completely tedious and boring to me. Had it not been for the onward trudging through the book, if there had been more happening, or if it had been written in such a way as to hold my attention, then I would have like it more. As it was I almost gave up on it halfway through, had to force myself to finish it, and then just didn’t really care at all about it after I was done.

    • maarvarq says:

      Pretty much my sentiments, although I found the contrived approach to gender (does really no race or species in this galaxy distinguish between male and female anywhere between “not at all” and ludicrously situation-specific?) removed a layer of texture from characters whose inherent blandness couldn’t afford to lose it, and also evoked 1984-style Newspeak. As a long-time reader of SF my “conceptual framework” is pretty broad already, thank you very much, so I had little trouble figuring out what was going on (not much, in short) and by the time anything really started to happen (halfway though a nearly 400 page book!) the author had lost me as far as caring an iota about any of the characters was concerned. Don’t get me started about the endless mentions of tea, or the way that an enormously old civilization doesn’t seem to have any better form of recreation than Ludo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludo_%28board_game%29

  3. Ruth2Day says:

    not sure this would be in my to read list. I know I should open myself up to sci-fi, but I just can’t seem to do so. nice review

  4. “Having your conceptual framework taken out for examination” is a very good phrase. I do enjoy doing that, but I also enjoy engaging plots, and several reviews have me worried about Ancillary Justice on that front. I love upsetting the gender binary! But I also love exciting plots and books that don’t make up a bunch of new words that I have to remember!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.