Review of “Adaptation” by Malinda Lo

This is a young adult scifi novel that combines some familiar tropes with some new twists.


Reese Holloway and David Li, juniors at Kennedy High School in San Francisco, are in Arizona for a national debate competition when planes start falling out of the sky. All of them allegedly crashed because of bird strikes. Reese, texting her BFF Julien, finds out that there are theories of a government cover-up of even more crashes than have been publicized, combined with a suspicious media blackout. Thus, Reese, David, and their debate coach decide to drive back to San Francisco instead of risking their lives in the air. But much goes wrong on the way, and Reese and David end up in a life-threatening accident close to Area 51.

[Area 51 is a secret military base in Nevada. Rumors have abounded over the years that this is where the military has sequestered extraterrestrials, and that this secret has been kept from the public (with or without government complicity, depending on the particular conspiracy theory).]


Reese, it must be noted, has been harboring a secret crush on David. Maybe David likes her back or maybe not. The accident makes all that moot. And when David and Reese are released from their hospital after a month of being in medical-induced comas to save their lives, all they know is that they are now different somehow … in a very freaky way.

Moreover, after they are back home, Reese meets a very striking girl, Amber, and develops a crush on her too.

Is this coming of age? Or something spookier? Because nothing has been the same since Reese and David were OPERATED ON in Area 51!

Discussion: For me, this book exhibited both strengths and weaknesses.

What I liked:

You have to love a book full of bisexual, gay, and straight characters and everyone is cool about it.

And did I mention mixed races of all sorts?

What I didn’t like:

Reese is 17, but she usually acts much younger. She can be incredibly naïve, immature and stupid for someone her age.

The girl-with-the-gay-best-friend plotline is getting old…

The actions taken on the roads by panicky people and a suddenly-fascist military seemed pretty unlikely to me.

The government official characters (each with names like Special Agent X) seemed more like over-the-top movie caricatures (wearing dark glasses of course) than realistic officials under those same circumstances.

Last but not least, there is a scene that is so Richard Dreyfuss-and-the-mashed-potatoes that I couldn’t believe the author would include it without having to include an acknowledgement to “Close Encounters of the Third Kind”!


Evaluation: Easy recipe for this book: Take a well-worn movie plot full of well-meaning aliens and evil government officials and re-tell it for a YA audience. Throw in all sorts of diversity. Add a semi-cliffhanger at the end so readers will be back for Book Two. (Some readers, that is…. Probably not this reader.)

Rating: 2.5/5

Published by Little, Brown and Company, a division of Hachette Book Group, Inc., 2012

About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Review of “Adaptation” by Malinda Lo

  1. Sandy says:

    Oy. Well, I will admit that the initial premise is appealing, but that the author let it turn into almost a parody or at least didn’t take it too seriously. Too bad because I actually might have read it had the plot held strong.

  2. Beth F says:

    Ok, you’ve convinced me to bypass this.

  3. Charlie says:

    Pity, because Ash was so good. I’m tempted to read it anyway, because of what you’ve said about people being cool about sexuality, it sounds just like Ash there and it was just so nice to read, but I’ll approach it with the knowledge of what you’ve said, because I think what you said otherwise would bug me too.

  4. BermudaOnion says:

    I do like that the characters’ sexuality isn’t an issue but, other than that, I don’t think the book is for me.

  5. sagustocox says:

    This does not sound like something for me at all. Thanks for the honest review

  6. my, much longer don’t like list than like list…moving along..nothing to see here.

  7. YA sci fi….love it. Probably not this one, but there are some others I’m giving a go. The 5th Wave maybe?

  8. Jenners says:

    Not for me I think.

  9. stacybuckeye says:

    What? A sequel you are going to skip? I think you might cave and read it even though this wasn’t up to par, haha 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.