Review of “The Affair” by Lee Child

Note: This review is by my husband Jim.

Fans of Lee Child may have wondered why Jack Reacher, Child’s popular protagonist, left the army. (Even in the first book in the series, Reacher was already an ex-Army M.P.) Child answers that question in The Affair, by going back in time to 1997 for the termination of Reacher’s military career, when Reacher was 36.


Most of the action takes place near Fort Kelham, a fictional army ranger base in Northern Mississippi, where Reacher has been sent to make sure the army is not implicated in the murder of a beautiful young townie. The young lady in question, who happened to be Caucasion, was the victim of a grizzly throat slashing, just the sort of killing a well-trained army ranger might be able to accomplish. It then transpires that two other local beautiful women were recently killed in an identical modus operandi, but being black, their murders caused hardly a ripple.

While in Mississippi, Reacher encounters some tough [but not nearly as tough as Reacher] Good Ol’ Boys, a beautiful ex-marine sheriff named Elizabeth Deveraux, and a sinister plot that extends high into the Pentagon. As one who has read Lee Child novels can expect, Reacher goes on to beat up the Good Ol’ Boys (six of them at one time), make passionate love to the ex-marine, and foil the sinister plot. In the process, the reader learns the extent of damage that (1) a freight train can do to a car; (2) a hunting knife can do to a throat; and (3) a well-timed head-butt can do to an unexpecting combatant.

Child is an expert at describing macho wise-cracking, verbal intimidation, and hand-to-hand combat. He is awful at describing sex. Unlike most of his books, this one contains several sex scenes, none of which is erotic, all of which could have been truncated. During the first and most explicit sex scene, I kept asking myself, “When is he going to finish?!” That scene was probably more painful because I was listening to an audio book and could not easily skip to the dénouement.

The reader of the audio version, Dick Hill, does a decent job of changing voices for the male characters; but when he indicates that a female is speaking, it is just painful. I’d have trouble being attracted to any woman who sounded like him even if she were gorgeous and intelligent.

Nevertheless, when he sticks to his knitting, Child can be very good, and this book is no exception. Child knows how to withhold just enough information from the reader to keep one off balance without being too gimmicky. The plot is nicely complicated, and the action outside the bedroom is fast-paced and handled with aplomb. Child uses repetition of verbal themes very effectively. For example, when Reacher says, “I said nothing,” you can almost hear ominous theme music playing in the background.

Evaluation: This isn’t the best Jack Reacher novel I’ve read, but it is not bad. Recommended for airport reading.

Note: This is the 16th book in the Jack Reacher series. I listened to the unabridged audio version on 11 compact discs.

Rating: 2.5/5

Audio version published by Random House Audio, 2011. The reader, Dick Hill, is a three-time winner of the Audie Award. [Insert by Jill: I listened to part of this tape with Jim, and I agree: when the reader tried to sound like a female, it was just laughable.]


About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Review of “The Affair” by Lee Child

  1. Beth F says:

    I think I’ve listened to books narrated by Dick Hill and I don’t remember having any issues with his female voices. Bummer. I haven’t read any of the Reacher books, but I keep meaning to.

  2. sandynawrot says:

    So I must be the only pervert that thought the sex scenes were hot! I almost couldn’t drive when those were going on, with that whole train and everything. Hahaha! Guess I need a little more action in my life! I don’t mind Dick Hill. He might not be right for every audio, but he is good for Reacher I think because he is abrupt and rough. I love his “Not. Good.” All his female voices sound alike but they haven’t bothered me. Guess I have just gotten used to them.

  3. I haven’t read (or listened to) anything by this author, but know hw is quite popular. Sounds like this was not one of his better books. Thanks to Jim for the review.

  4. BermudaOnion says:

    I listened to this one too and laughed through the sex scenes. It was my first Reacher book and didn’t wow me. I guess I need to try another one but I’m not too motivated after this one.

  5. Charlie says:

    Well it doesn’t sound particularly good (cringeworthy sex scenes), but I might have to see if I can find an audio sample of the narration. Sounds a strange set-up!

  6. zibilee says:

    Sandy loves these books, and I have borrowed the first from the library, so I will have to see if they are for me or not. I do like rough and tumble guy characters, and as long as the sex scenes aren’t squicky, I don’t mind them either. I am glad that you thought this was a good one, Jim. I like it that the books appeal to a wide audience.

  7. Bad sex scenes on audio can not be pleasant! Love the way you categorized it-airport reading-should become a real category, along with YA and chic lit-thanks.

  8. Belle Wong says:

    I’ve been on a Reacher spree (finally got around to reading the Killing Floor last week – I’d only ever read Bad Luck and Trouble before that). Realized that Reacher isn’t the typical lone wolf hero who gets beat up again and again until he wins the final battle, bloodied but unbowed. I like that he wins all his fights! I’ve been speeding through the audiobooks ever since. Haven’t gotten to this one yet, but definitely will 🙂

  9. JoV says:

    It’s interesting to note that the Jack Reacher series have run for 16 books and I have yet to read one! i must read the book soon. great review.

  10. stacybuckeye says:

    If it’s got Jack I’ll be reading it even if it’s not the best 🙂

  11. Jenners says:

    Male narrators doing female voices can be very very offputting!

  12. RichardJ says:

    My opinion: Jack Reacher turns out to be a plain murderer.

    In this book, Jack kills three people:
    -without being threatened or harmed by these people;
    -without acting out of self-defense;
    -without a proper court trial;
    -without authorization to kill these people.
    So legally Jack is a just common murderer.

    I think Lee Child passes the thin line between good and bad.
    Surprisingly nobody seems to bother …..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.