Review of “Necromancing The Stone” by Lish McBride

Note: There are mild spoilers for Hold Me Closer, Necromancer, and a mild but warning-prefaced and font-color-protected spoiler for this second book, Necromancing the Stone.

Although this is a sequel to Hold Me Closer, Necromancer (see my review, here), the author has the protagonist explain right on page one what he has gone through lately, and by this means, we get all caught up without having to re-read.

I was quite surprised at how much I liked the first book in this series, because after all, it features necromancers, satyrs, vampires, werewolves, gnomes, furies, and every other sort of paranormal creature you can imagine (and some you can’t!). But the author’s clever puns and hilarious send-ups delighted me, so I quite looked forward to this follow-up book. My expectations might have been too high, however.

Sam LaCroix, a funny and likable college dropout in Seattle, found out in Book One that he is actually a necromancer (which is someone who can communicate with the dead, either by summoning their spirits or raising them bodily). In a fight for his life against another (but evil) necromancer, Douglas Montgomery, Sam’s best friend Ramon was turned into a werebear, his friend Brooke was decapitated, and he fell in love with the half-werewolf, half-fey-hound heir-apparent to lead the local werewolf pack, Bridin Blackthorn. It was quite a year for him.

In Book Two, we find Sam living, along with his friends Ramon and Frank, in Douglas Montgomery’s old house. He has the services of James, the resident house spirit (or “pukis”); Brooke, who is now Sam’s “ghostly girl Friday”; and Ashley, a “Harbinger” who serves as a go-between for souls. (She renders occasional help to Sam in exchange for waffles with whipped cream and real maple syrup.) Sam is being trained by Brid’s brothers in self-defense; he is still dating Brid; and he is contemplating his interesting life when everything changes.


It turns out Montgomery is still alive, and he is out for blood – specifically, Sam’s blood and the blood of everyone Sam cares about. Somehow, Sam has to figure out how to “find” Montgomery from his netherworld location, and put a stop to the carnage before Montgomery puts a stop to him.

Evaluation: Although Lish McBride again adds plenty of wit to her ongoing story of Sam and his paranormal companions, I liked the first book better. I came to this sequel expecting the same sort of zaniness that prevailed in Book One. In this book, the author spends more time developing the characters and exploring moral dilemmas. Yes, McBride evinces skill in her warm portrayal of love and loyalty and friendship, but at the same time she tries to maintain the first book’s tone of a very humorous burlesque featuring quirky paranormals of every stripe. I found this odd mix of whimsy and solid stuff a bit disconcerting. That said, who can resist such characters as Stanley, the affectionate (albeit dead) elk with the velvety nose? I’ll definitely be back for book three!

Rating: 3.5/5

Published by Henry Holt and Company, 2012

About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Review of “Necromancing The Stone” by Lish McBride

  1. Rachel says:

    Well, pooh – that’s disappointing. I’ll still read it though in hopes that book 3 will be as good as book 1. Have you read the e-book that is Ashley’s backstory? I haven’t but I need to – it’s only 33 pages long and free in the Kindle store right now. It’s called Necromancer: A Novella.

    • Rachel, I should add that I’m in the minority with finding it disappointing. I really think it has more to do with what I was looking for than with what the author provided! (No, I have not read Ashley’s backstory but I hope to get to it one of these days!)

      • CuriousSue says:

        I’m in that minority right beside you, Jill. The first book was a surprise and a delight, so my expectations were too high for this one. I felt like too much time was spent on explaining what had gone before, making this a slower book. Also, without making spoilery comments about the end of the first book, all I can say is that I had thought the last chapter of Hold Me Closer had set us up for a completely different story than the one I read, so I spent 200 pages looking for the wrong story, much like Alicia Silverstone kept looking at the wrong boy in Clueless.

  2. I love the title but not the paranormal concept.

  3. Ah, Kathy beat me to it- I was going to say pretty much the same thing – awesome title, even though I’m not into the paranormal thing. 🙂

  4. Jenners says:

    This is the second book review I’ve read that mentioned a werebear. And I don’t think they were the same book!! I never heard of a were bear before last week.

  5. Werebear? Ha.
    Also, I’d do a lot for waffles with whipped cream too. Mmmm.

  6. This sounds so utterly strange that I almost have to read it!

  7. bookingmama says:

    Ummmm.. probably not for me. But I give the author credit for originality! LOL!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.