Review of “Once” by Anna Carey

Note: This is Book Two of the “Eve” Series. Book Two has a Big Reveal but I’m not going to spoil it! On the other hand, my review will necessarily have spoilers for Book One, so skip to the Evaluation Section if you have not read Eve.

In Book One we meet Eve, one of many children left without parents by the plague that killed 98% of the population. Eve attends an all-female orphan school, where the girls are taught that upon graduation, they will take up exciting careers to help rebuild the planet. But the night before the ceremony, Eve finds out that instead of moving on to career training, all graduates are transferred to a hospital in which they become brood mares to populate New America. She and another girl from school, Arden, escape.

Quickly Eve and Arden run into trouble, but they are rescued by a male orphan, Caleb, who takes them to the relative safety of a hidden camp. Before long, Eve and Caleb fall in love.

All is not well in paradise, however, because Eve is being pursued by troops of the “king” of New America. She assumes it is because she was the top student at the orphanage. Although the camp is underground and should be safe, Eve and Arden are betrayed by one of the boys who is jealous that Eve likes Caleb instead of him. Eve and Arden are taken away by a bounty hunter but escape, meet up with Caleb again, and make their way to Califia, a refuge in San Francisco. Califia is for girls only though, so Eve and Caleb have to part, vowing to find each other again.

As Once begins, Eve has been in Califia for three months. The women of Califia don’t want her there though, because her presence endangers them since Eve is still being sought by the king’s troops. (Now she is convinced she is wanted so she can be the king’s personal brood mare.) Once again Eve is betrayed, and she and Arden are taken away. Arden is left at the breeding hospital, and Eve is brought to the City of Sand, home of the king.

The tension ratchets way up as we wonder why Eve has been brought to the City of Sand, what will befall Arden, and what ever happened to Caleb.

Discussion: I re-read Eve before starting Once, and was glad I did; I actually liked the first book much better the second time. That is often the case for me, however; the first time through in a book, I race through to find out what happens, and overlook a lot.

In my more considered reading of Eve, I discovered that quite a bit of the story is devoted to the problems all the orphans have in understanding what “love” is. First Eve comes to think that love is

“…bearing witness. That it was the act of watching someone’s life, of simply being there to say: your life is worth seeing.

Then she learns a bit more about it and explains to a little boy:

“‘Love is just…’ I searched for the right words. ‘…caring about someone very deeply. Feeling like that person matters to you, like your whole world would be sadder without them in it.’”

Later, she learns a harsher lesson about love:

“I began to weep, finally knowing the truth: love was death’s only adversary, the only thing powerful enough to combat its clawing, desperate grasp.”

These insights are more fully developed in Once, as Eve gets more meaningful opportunities to find out about different types of love, friendship, and loyalty, and what they mean to her life.

Evaluation: Once manages to avoid the trilogy middle-child syndrome and ramps up the quotient of both suspense and sweetness.

Thus, I’m happy to say I liked this one even more than Eve; Once has more depth, and shows a more developed skill by the author, in my opinion. I can’t wait to see what happens in the third book!

Rating: 4/5

Published by Harper, an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers, 2012


About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Review of “Once” by Anna Carey

  1. Heather says:

    I didn’t have any interest in these books before, although I’ve seen Eve around a few times, but you made me think twice! Maybe I’ll pick these up.

  2. I have Eve but I haven’t read it yet.

  3. Sandy says:

    You know, the writing is beautiful! But I’m not sure I’d pick these up if I just heard the premise. These books all sound the same!!!

  4. zibilee says:

    I think I like the sound of these. They sound like they are a bit on par with Wither and Fever, but much better executed. I feel like I need to know more, and should probably try to get these from the library when I can. I am glad the second book avoided the sophomore slump!

  5. Okay, okay, you ARE the Queen of Ya Dystopia!

  6. Julie P. says:

    I rarely go back and re-read a book but the few times I do, I find that I do discover new meanings.

  7. Beth F says:

    I haven’t read either so I skipped to the evaluation — I love YA dystopian. What does that say about me?

  8. stacybuckeye says:

    Huh. This doesn’t look like your type of book at all. (insert wink or eye roll) As with most of these types of books you’ve made me want to pick it up despite myself!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s