TLC Book Tour Review of “The Baker’s Daughter” by Sarah McCoy

Note: This book is reviewed as part of TLC Tours.

Quite a few books try to juxtapose two stories, past and present, but often one or the other of the segments doesn’t work out so well. Not so with this book: both are very satisfactory, and moreover each parallels the other as the story progresses, to create a synergistic enhancement of the whole.

The story from the past centers around 16-year-old Elsie Schmidt, the daughter in a family with a bakery in Garmisch, Germany at the time of World War II. Elsie has helped out in the bakery ever since her older sister, Hazel, left for Steinhoering to enter the Lebensborn Program.

[This project was founded by Heinrich Himmler in 1935, with the goal of increasing the number of racially “pure” children in Germany. Himmler’s idea was to encourage SS and army officers to “mate” with approved young women (i.e., blonde hair, blue eyes, and “pure” family lineage traceable back at least three generations). (You know, children who resembled the Aryan ideal of Hitler. Oh wait….) The children were then taken to nurseries, evaluated, and if they passed the test, they were given to SS families to raise. If not, they were eliminated. In The Baker’s Daughter, Hazel goes to the first Lebensborn home that was opened; eventually there were ten of them. In order to maximize the results, Himmler ordered all SS and police to father as many children as possible. Still, it wasn’t happening fast enough for Himmler. He then had the SS start kidnapping children from racially acceptable countries and transferring them to Lebensborn centers to be indoctrinated. If the children thus taken refused to cooperate, they were sent to extermination camps. (In 1946, it was estimated that more than 250,000 children were kidnapped from outside of Germany. After the war, only 25,000 were sent back to their families. In some cases, it was the children themselves who refused to go back, having been successfully converted by Nazi propaganda.)]

We get a taste of what Hazel goes through from her correspondence with Elsie. But of course she must be circumspect in her letters, and so the full horror of being a brood mare in this system of legalized rape was not fully developed. But readers are given enough information to imagine what it may have been like.

For Elsie, life is a bit better, but there is still the omnipresent threat of Nazis who are corrupt with power and the ability to eliminate those who stand in their way. One of these Nazis, Josef, nearly twice her age, asks her to marry him. He seems nicer than the others, though she doesn’t love him. On the other hand, she realizes that an engagement to him is a way to provide protection for herself and her family. But on Christmas Eve, 1944, suddenly everything changes.

In the present-day story, we meet Elsie 63 years later, running her own bakery in El Paso, Texas, along with her 45-year-old daughter Jane. Reba Adams, a local reporter, comes to the bakery to interview Elsie for a Christmas feature, and immediately bonds with Elsie and Jane. Reba is somewhat estranged from her own family, because of unresolved family traumas from her past. Her older sister Deedee urges her to stop judging: “let God be the judge.” She counsels:

“We have to stop being afraid of the shadows and realize that the world is made up of shades of gray, light and darkness. Can’t have one without the other.”

Reba’s inability to see gray extends to herself: she is so afraid of any darkness within her that she has constructed an artificial persona to face the world. Therefore she too, like Elsie once did, struggles with an engagement to be married. Her boyfriend Riki loves her, but Reba fears actually marrying him. The Reba that Riki knows is a lie. Would he still love her if he knew who she really was?

Riki has his own demons. He works for the Border Patrol in El Paso, and has to arrest and evict people who are only trying to survive. While not directly parallel to the case in World War II with Nazis arresting and evicting Jews, some of the same issues arise: when should the rule of law be forsaken in the name of decency? And if you don’t help to save others from injustice, will you lose yourself along with them?

Evaluation: As Seamus Heaney observed when he accepted the 1995 Nobel Prize, “…the documents of civilization have been written in blood and tears.” He cautioned, “We are rightly suspicious of that which gives too much consolation in these circumstances.” And yet, he goes on to say, humans are also capable of heroic virtue and redemption. Admirably, the author shows us both sides of the coin, giving us much to consider about our past as well as our present.

I’m so glad my husband was out of town when I finished this, so he couldn’t hear my banshee-like sobbing wailing noises. Get some Kleenex and read this one!

Rating: 4/5

Note: There are a lot of fascinating issues for a book club to discuss, and you could even make treats for your meeting from some of the great recipes included in the back!

Published by Crown, an imprint of the Crown Publishing Group, a division of Random House, Inc., 2012


About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review, Tour and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

24 Responses to TLC Book Tour Review of “The Baker’s Daughter” by Sarah McCoy

  1. I really like the sound of this one Jill. Glad u enjoyed it as well; have a great week.

  2. This was definitely a good one!!!

  3. I am adding this one to my TBR list asap. I’ve heard nothing but good things about it, and I am a fan of WWII books.

  4. Sandy says:

    I absolutely LOVED this book. Even with the tears and emotions, I adored the characters and the story and WWII. Plus McCoy is just a precious person. I am so happy for her to have this success with her book.

  5. BermudaOnion says:

    I really want to read this one. I adore Sarah – after all, she’s a Hokie! I will be sure to have my tissues handy when I read it.

  6. Beth F says:

    Just thinking about this book brings tears to my eyes. I am *not* a crier, but Sarah had me sobbing!

  7. Wonderful review — this was a really powerful book and I loved the juxtaposition of eras/themes to tell a moving story. You captured the novel’s feel perfectly!

  8. Four stars and a box of Kleenex ..oh my, I best be prepared when I read this one.

  9. Julie P. says:

    So glad you enjoyed this one! I loved the book and the author!

  10. zibilee says:

    I can’t imagine what life must have been like for those poor women, and even thinking about it makes me shudder. This book sounds like it was profound in so many ways, and that it also made you think about not only the situations of the past, but what happens everyday here at the border. Incredible and absolutely absorbing review today, Jill. I am suggesting this one when it’s my turn to pick at the next club meeting.

  11. I agree that McCoy handled both storylines wonderfully! I loved this book and teared up, too. Not as much as with The Lost Wife, but still. Glad you really enjoyed this one, too!

  12. softdrink says:

    I really need to grab this one off of the shelf!

  13. Sarah says:

    Jill! Thank you so, so much for this amazingly thoughtful, insightful, lovely review. I’m thrilled you enjoyed my story so much and hope your readers do too! Such a pleasure to meet you through this book blog tour for the paperback release. I’ve added your blog to my computer’s “Bookish Faves” bookmark bar–let’s definitely keep in touch, my southwest friends! Tucson is just a hop-skip away.

  14. Brooke says:

    I keep promising myself I’m going to read this one, but I really think I’d love to make it a book club selection one month. That means putting if off until 2013 which kind of sucks. I’ve been sitting here trying to remember a book that impressed with with a dual narrative, past and present, and nothing comes to mind. Hopefully, this book will change that!

  15. sagustocox says:

    I LOVED this novel! And Sarah is such a cutie and so sweet!

  16. Trish says:

    I only read the last two paragraphs of this post because I don’t want to know ANYTHING about this one going in (except now I know that it’s a tear jerker). Seems everyone really loves this one and I can’t wait to read it in the next two weeks in prep for my book club (where we’ll actually be skyping with McCoy!). I’m hoping that someone will bring treats to our meeting.

  17. Alex says:

    What is up with all the “The [insert job here] Daughter” titles out there? Weird…

  18. Always less embarrassing to weep over books in private! 🙂 I don’t think I’ve seen a negative review of this one yet.

  19. Ti says:

    Another sobbing episode?? I’ve shed a tear a couple of times over books but not nearly as much as you! If Jim had been around, what would his reaction have been?

  20. Lisa says:

    I’ve got this one coming up soon – really can’t wait for it now, but good to know I need to keep the Kleenex handy.

  21. stacybuckeye says:

    I don’t have the energy to devote to that much wailing!

  22. I agree that most books don’t get the balance of past and present just right; glad to see that McCoy does such a great job with that in this book!

    Thanks for being on the tour!

  23. Staci@LifeintheThumb says:

    Loved this one too!! I would’ve cried right along with you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.