Review of “A Song For Summer” by Eva Ibbotson

Long Version of Review:

If you have read any of my previous reviews of books by Eva Ibbotson, you already more or less know the plot: The protagonist is a young, beautiful girl who is well-born but eschews her status as part of her love and appreciation for the little joys in life, including domesticity, nature, and rewards reaped from kindness. She is loved by all, including the surly, the old, the young, the birds and the bees. Along comes a princely type who falls for her goodness and simplicity as well as her beauty. Alas, he believes he belongs to another, and she believes he belongs to another, and they go their separate ways. But they never forget each other, and in the end, their love triumphs.

Ibbotson’s books are very, very similar. And yet, there are enough differences in each to make the predictability seem familiar and endearing rather than annoying. It’s amazing to me that this is the case, and yet, other Ibbotson fans concur: we love Eva Ibbotson in spite of the fact that we can safely and reliably predict the arc of every single story.

In A Song For Summer, Ellen Carr, in her early twenties, fits the usual Ibbotson profile of small, thin, blonde, and beautiful. Additionally, she has big brown eyes, and is known for being both clever and kind. (In a departure from other Ibbotson heroines, Ellen is not ditsy.) Ellen answers an ad to take a domestic post in Corinthia in the southern end of Austria, in a school at Schloss Hallendorf specializing in music, dama, and dance. (Ibbotson’s books tend to be set in castles, and always involve music, opera, and ballet.) There are flowers everywhere, tended by the mysterious, kind, resourceful and handsome Marek Tarnowsky, age 29, who looks like every other Ibbotson hero: broad-shouldered, with blunt, irregular features, and penetrating eyes.

Marek turns out to be leading a secret life – one both exceptional and noble: he is helping stranded European Jews escape from the Nazis. Moreover, he is a music prodigy. And yet, here he is doing landscaping at the castle. Ellen suspects there is more to Marek than meets the eye, and doesn’t shirk from danger when she too has an opportunity to help save Jews. There are some notable moments in this book when both Marek and Ellen work to rescue the talented violinist Isaac Meierwitz. Marek claims that Isaac is his friend and he “can’t allow” Ellen to take this risk:

“‘Don’t!’ She turned on him furiously. ‘Just don’t dare to say this is no job for a woman. My mother and my aunts didn’t get kicked by police horses and thrown to the ground [in the struggle for women’s rights] for you to go around treating me as an imbecile. Furthermore, if war comes no one will bother to distinguish between men and women. Ask the women of Guernica whether anyone cared what sex they were when they bombed the marketplace. Getting Isaac out is part of fighting Hitler and I won’t be left out of it.’”

I liked the fact that Ibbotson balanced Ellen’s love of cooking and cleaning and sewing with a firm commitment to rights for women.

At one point, Isaac wonders why their contacts – religious Jews – would take risks on Isaac who was practically an atheist:

“But he knew. He himself had scarcely set foot in a synagogue; his mother had been baptized, but Hitler had created a new kind of Jew – someone who existed to be hunted and killed – and [therefore] these unknown men had accepted him as a brother.”

I thought that was an exceptionally perceptive observation.

Isaac, like everyone else, falls in love with Ellen, with “her strange mixture of softness and steel.” But it is only Marek that she wants, which leads us to:

Short Version of Review (with thanks to the longer poem by Pablo Neruda):

“if each day,
each hour, 

you feel that you are destined for me 

with implacable sweetness, 

if each day a flower 

climbs up to your lips to seek me, 

ah my love, ah my own, 

in me all that fire is repeated, 

in me nothing is extinguished or forgotten, 

my love feeds on your love, beloved, 

and as long as you live it will be in your arms 

without leaving mine.

From “If You Forget Me” by Pablo Neruda”

Evaluation: This book has all the usual Eva Ibbotson bare bones, fleshed out by a story of courage and enduring love. I adore all of her books. In spite of their sameness, each one has a bit of something new, and both parts are equally appealing.

Rating: 4/5

Paperback edition published in the U.S. by Speak, an imprint of Penguin Group (USA) Inc., 2007


About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to Review of “A Song For Summer” by Eva Ibbotson

  1. Sandy says:

    I love the Nazi twist here (Marek is a distinctly Polish name), even though overall it sounds like it has strains of sweetness ala Disney. Sometimes one needs a little gentleness to heal our abused minds!

  2. It’s several years since I read this but I remember loving it, Ellen is a great character and the book is full of gentle humour.

  3. Staci@LifeintheThumb says:

    I really need to add these to my reading!

  4. Bookworm1858 says:

    They’re all so similar but I love them all-I just love seeing them on my shelf, especially since their covers all match!

  5. zibilee says:

    Your love for this author and her books is inspiring, and though the plots may be similar, there is something about the way that this story is told that really intrigues me. It’s about time for some Ibbotson to join my list of novels on the shelf. P.S.- The inclusion of that poem was beautiful and brilliant.

  6. Beth F says:

    Ditto what Heather said about the poem. I’ve always wanted to read Ibbotson, I even own a couple of her books. Not at all sure why I haven’t actually read or listened to them.

  7. BermudaOnion says:

    I don’t think I would have heard about this author if it wasn’t for you. I really need to try her work.

  8. JoV says:

    Heard so much about Eva Ibbotson. If there is one book I should read, which one should I start? (if it is all almost similar!)

  9. This sounds wonderful, I like how you say that even thought the authors books are similar, they still hold their own and still draw you to them.

  10. I’ve been wanting to read this one since I saw such good reviews during the WWII challenge a few years back. Love the long/short reviews!

  11. Jenners says:

    Hmmm….I just don’t know if I could read the same book over and over again. BUt I trust you.

  12. I own this one already, so no excuse not to get to it soon! I’ve been craving Ibbotson lately. You’re right; the appeal of her books is both in how familiar they all are and in the little details that make each one unique despite the similar plot structure.

  13. Alex says:

    A Ibbotson heroine that’s not ditsy? Count me in! I feel about this author the way I do about Heyer: I sooooo want to love her, most of the reader who’s opinions I respect love her, but somehow, I just start to pick on everything from page 1. And these books are not be the overly analysed, scrutinized and rationalized, are they?

  14. stacybuckeye says:

    I do typically get annoyed when authors write the same story over and over again, but there are some who do it well. What is the best book to start with (where it will be all new and shiny :))?

  15. Jenny says:

    I always think Eva Ibbotson does a wonderful job of portraying bravery in the face of Nazism. I know her books are all the same, but still she never fails to move me when she writes books set during Hitler times. I tear up every single time. I am predictable that way.

  16. JuneA** says:

    I’ve had Ibbotson on my TBR list for a while, but haven’t managed to get to it. I think I’ll move her up the list! I call books like this “comfort reads” . The good always triumphs bad, and love always, always wins! Like Austen & Heyer – when I’m stuck indoors, that’s what I want to read!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s