Review of “Jellicoe Road” by Melina Marchetta

I loved this intricately plotted, expertly structured book, which won the 2009 Michael L. Prinz Award for literary merit in a book for teens. The cover looks very YA-ish, and there is certainly a coming-of-age part to the book, but truthfully, I would not call it a YA novel. At the very least, I would call it a crossover.

It’s not easy to read at first; like other reviewers, I felt very lost for at least the first fifty pages. And yet, there was something about it that made me want to keep going, rather than to engage in my usual reaction of driving the book back to the library with all due speed. It ended up, for me, being a lot like the movie “Sixth Sense” in that, as soon as I was done, I had to go back and start again so I could see what I had missed before! (So yes, I read this twice in a row!)

One half of the the story is centered around Taylor Markham, a 17-year-old [female] senior at Jellicoe School, which is a boarding school out in the bush in Australia for those who either don’t have parents, or whose parents find it convenient to send their kids elsewhere. Every autumn there is a “war” waged between the students: the “townies” of Jellicoe, and the military cadets from a school in Sydney. The cadets set up camp by the school each September as part of an outdoor training program. Taylor, whose mother abandoned her on the Jellicoe Road when she was eleven, has been around the longest, so she is voted as the leader of the students for the war. Chaz Santangelo, son of the police chief, is the leader of the townies, and the cadets are led by Jonah Griggs, whom Taylor identifies as “not just a name but a state of mind…”

As if all this weren’t complicated enough, interwoven among Taylor’s story is another, concerning five kids from twenty-some years previously. Their story is told more in bits and pieces, and in a way is the more fascinating for it. We don’t know for quite some time whether it is fact or fiction, nor how it is related to what is taking place in the present.

The gradual revelation though, is what drives the story forward, and comes to supply its heart and soul.

Discussion: Taylor is a complex character: defensive, reckless, brave, but scared of a lot too: of being close to people; of being dependent on them; and of trusting them. Being abandoned by her mother defined her early life; assuming others want to abandon her colors the rest of it. There are a number of people who want to love her, but either they can’t let themselves for their own reasons, or she pushes them away for hers. So she is a loner, and wonders if not having anyone to grieve over you if you die would mean that you are worth less as a person.

In spite of all this need, however, for love and friendship from other people, Taylor wants them to figure it out without her asking; that way there is no risk to her. So she doesn’t ask because she doesn’t have trust, and thus she doesn’t receive. But as the story progresses, Taylor comes to realize that life is too short for waiting for more from it, and if she wants more, she needs “to go and get it, demand it, take hold of it with all my might, and do the best I can with it.” Her growing process is both painful and exhilarating in its realism. It is perhaps expressed best by her realization about sex the first time she has it: it might hurt; hurt a lot even; but you can figure out together how to do it better until it becomes something else; until it becomes everything.

Evaluation: This is such a moving and well-crafted book that the effects of the story were hard to shake after I finished. Normally, I would not even persevere if I were so at sea at the beginning of a book, but I trust enough in the Prinz Award to know it would be worth an effort, and indeed it was.

And it has been hard to review without spoilers, but I can say (not too helpfully) it’s about love and trust and friendship and loyalty, and in a year of great reading, is right up there for me with the top tier of books. And I can add this: I did something with this book I’ve never done before. As I mentioned above, the day after I finished, I opened the book, and reread it again. I knew that this time, I would know what everything in the beginning meant, and there was a lot to gain from going back. And I swear, even though I had just read it two days before, it was even better the second time! I fell in love with this author, and immediately put in a request at the library for her other books. I just wanted to take this book to bed with me and hug it because it was so wonderful. Highly recommended!

Rating: 4.5/5

Published by HarperTeen, an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers, 2008


About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Review of “Jellicoe Road” by Melina Marchetta

  1. yay! I’ve been waiting for your review. 🙂 and I agree, great book! And good call about how the sex illustrates the larger point about relationships in general. So much to appreciate in this novel.

  2. Rachel says:

    Wow, this sounds like a great book – I’ll have to check it out.

  3. BermudaOnion says:

    The people at my local bookstore love this book too. If I get the chance to read it, I’ll have to remember that the beginning is confusing. You’ve made me want to give it a go.

  4. zibilee says:

    I love they way you’ve expressed your emotions about this book, and though I have heard it touted as one of the greatest books out there, I never had a desire to read it before. Now that I have read your review, I really want to get this one quickly! I love it when you take a chance on something puzzling, and it ends up being moving and brilliant! Great job with this review! You’ve made me really excited about this book!

  5. Biblibio says:

    This is less a comment about the book itself, more about the fact that I tend to view the Printz award as the most reliable of any literary award I’ve ever encountered. Their prize-winners tend to be a cut above the rest, and even without your strong endorsement of Jellicoe Road, I probably would have picked it up. But now, having read your review, I feel a bit more confident regardless…

  6. Jenny says:

    Wow!! I don’t know/remember if you’ve read Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close, but that was a book I wanted to hug when I finished, LOL. And I have never once read a book twice in a row… I’m super interested in this one. I had already been interested in reading this but hadn’t heard much about it. I like that you consider it more crossover because even though I do read YA, I think it being geared towards younger readers has kept me from picking it up at times.

  7. I knew this one sounded familiar and realized when you mentioned the Prinz award that I had seen reviews a couple of years back. I hadn’t remembered what it was about though. Your review totally makes me want to track down a copy, so this is going on the wish list.

  8. bookingmama says:

    Oooh! I want this one!!!!

  9. Keishon says:

    I LOVE this book. LOVE IT. I’ve went on to read her backlist with the exception of her fantasy and The Piper’s Son – her latest contemporary. Not sure if I’ll read the fantasy stuff but she does contemporary really really well.

  10. This sounds like a beautiful story. Thank you for your recommendation. I am adding it to my TBR now.

  11. Staci@LifeintheThumb says:

    So what you’re really saying is that I should give this one another shot???? I took it back to the library after trying to read it a few years ago!

  12. stacybuckeye says:

    This one looks good, but it’s probably too much work for me right now. My mind is NOT craving challenging books right now. Too bad because if you read it back to back it must be good!

  13. Monica says:

    I have to read this book for English class, and I’ve been procrastinating on it and I don’t seem to interested. The first couple pages made kinda ehh but I think I will give it another shot (:

  14. Joyce says:

    Love your review of Jellicoe Road! This book is phenomenal, and it completely wrecked me. Melina Marchetta is one of my favourite authors now, thanks to this book. It’s been weeks since I finished it, but it still haunts me.

    I wrote a review about it over at my blog (, if you’d like to check it out!

    ~ Joyce

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.