Review of “Dark Water” by Laura McNeal

This coming of age/young love story is a departure from the usual young adult fare. It utilizes the elemental forces of fire and water to help tell the story, enriching it for the reader by the multiple layers of meaning in the text. There is so much in this book to stimulate the mind of readers: the symbolism of the life-giving role of water, and of the dual nature of fire that simultaneously connotes death but also the opportunity for clear-cutting renewal; the question of what constitutes communication: must you use the same language? can methods of communication other than speech allow you to communicate just as well?; and the notion of home: is it where you live or with whom you love? Is it with whom you were placed by chance of birth, or with the person who can see into your very soul? And interwoven throughout is the theme of an everlasting love that admits no barriers, even when the odds of overcoming them are overwhelming.

Pearl DeWitt is fifteen, and has heterochromia: one eye is blue and the other is brown. This physical split is echoed by other aspects of her life: her father left because he could not abide her mother, and her mother cannot get past the anger she feels over the desertion. Pearl and her mother now have to live in a guest cottage on her Uncle’s ranch in Fallbrook, California, where Pearl feels like an outsider. Furthermore, although Pearl is able to get by in the real world with her friends, she feels most comfortable in the dreamlike existence of fantasy and nature (so often fantastical): a world that her friends, now grown, no longer wish to inhabit. Pearl is, as Amiel – the 17-year-old boy she comes to love – says, de dos mundos – of two worlds.

Amiel is of two worlds as well. He is an illegal immigrant from Mexico who must constantly hide from authorities, but the California farmers near the border depend on him and others like him for labor. His native tongue is Spanish, but he also understands English. Ironically, he can hardly speak aloud in either language because of a tragic incident when he was young; nevertheless, he has learned to communicate in other ways. He wants to be with Pearl, but fears he would never be admitted to her world.

Pearl and Amiel slowly develop a relationship in spite of the many obstacles dividing them, until the Agua Prieta fire roars through their area. It destroys the not only bridges they were building between one another, but those connecting others to their lives as well.

Discussion: The motif of transmogrification permeates the story. Pearl’s mother has a tank full of caterpillars she nurtures, hoping to collect the silk one day from their cocoons. Pearl too is poised on the cusp of a transformation, hers analogous to the oyster: she struggles to come into her own as a person as beautiful as her nacreous name, but there is much in her life she doesn’t understand, and many situations in which she doesn’t know the right thing to do. After the fire, she muses:

“They say that parts of a teenager’s brain aren’t formed yet. That might have been the problem. I’d like to think that rather than a malignancy of heart.”

Amiel’s harrowing situation is one we live with every day in Southern Arizona. There are many young men who take put their lives in danger in order to get across the border and earn a living. They work extremely hard and live in impoverished conditions so they can send money home to their families. Those who try to cross legally are at the mercy of the very corrupt Mexican police force and often find their money taken without receiving permission to exit the country. We have had friends, who, like Amiel, refused to go for help when sick or injured because of the fear of getting deported. In this book, Amiel is more afraid of the fire fighters than the fire itself, because authorities are a danger to him, as is a home-grown “posse” trying to drive out the migrant workers. Amiel’s story is presented in a low-key way as just one of the many barriers against a relationship forming with Pearl, but it is told with a sensitivity and compassion so often missing in the current political landscape.

Another part of this book that rang very true for me was the ability to communicate between Pearl and Amiel. Living in a bilingual culture, I have been impressed with how well one can get to the heart of meaning even if one doesn’t know the words with which to communicate directly. These two have additional bonds to draw upon: they both know each other is an outsider, and they both are “coming-of-age” teens, who can connect powerfully through their shared longing and hope and inchoate love that makes every day seem shimmering with possibility.

Homes go up in flames at Valley Oaks mobile home park as Rice Fire destroys at least 100 homes in October 2007 near Fallbrook, California.

Wildfires and the fear and loss that accompany them also come close to my own experience, living in the Southwest. In this book, McNeal incorporates the fictional Agua Prieta Fire, but it closely resembles the actual Rice Canyon area of the October 2007 California wildfires. Overall, at least 1,500 homes were destroyed and over 500,000 acres burned from Santa Barbara County to the U.S.–Mexico border. In Fallbrook and outlying areas, 9,000 acres burned and 45,000 had to evacuate. The cause was never ascertained, but similar to when fires start in Southern Arizona, immigrants are generally suspected. Rarely do newscasters document the devastating effects on teenagers caught in the maelstrom; the author fills this gap by writing imaginatively of the reactions of Pearl, her cousin, and her classmates.

No matter the issue, McNeal’s prose is beautifully evocative, like this passage about the scorching hot day before the fire:

“On September 13, we were the kindling, and a monstrous god leaned over us to breathe. Clouds melted brush trembled, and the ocean burned white like molten glass. Palm fronds crashed into roads. Leaves swirled in the parking lot. My nose bled and my skin cracked. I breathed cotton-dry breaths through paper lips and dreamed of Amiel in the heat.”

Evaluation: The relationship between the two teenage protagonists is choreographed like a gentle ballet of two reticent people who sense that the acceptance they crave can finally be found with one another. But it is not just a story about love. It is a story about deciding what is wrong and what is right, and having the moral courage to embrace the ethical choice no matter the consequences.

This author is a gem, and her books are well worth seeking out.

Rating: 3.8/5

Note: National Book Award Finalist

Published by Alfred A. Knopf, an imprint of Random House Children’s Books, a division of Random House, Inc., 2010


About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

18 Responses to Review of “Dark Water” by Laura McNeal

  1. Marie says:

    sounds like such a fantastic book and one that i’d love!

  2. zibilee says:

    What an amazing and elegantly written review! I do have to admit that I am very intrigued by this book after having read your thoughts on it. It sounds extremely nuanced and layered, and something about the way that you expressed your thoughts about it makes me very intrigued about trying this one out for myself. It sounds like a beautiful story. Thanks for the fantastic review, Jill!

  3. celawerd says:

    This sounds like a fantastic book. Great review!

  4. sandynawrot says:

    Wow. Excellent review! I think we may have this book in our library at school, but it doesn’t get much love. I may have to do some pushing.

  5. Barbara says:

    Lovely review, Jill.

  6. Jenny says:

    Wow! Tons of symbolism and things to talk about! I was going to say it sounds like a great book to read and discuss with teens, but now I’m thinking it would work just as well for adults too!

  7. Katy says:

    Such a fantastic review! I read this a while back and have been meaning to review it – I can’t come anywhere close to writing one as insightful as this one is. Well done!

  8. BermudaOnion says:

    The symbolism would probably be over my head but I love the fact that the book explores what is right and what is wrong.

  9. Julie P. says:

    I’m with Kathy. I don’t even know the meaning of the words in your review! LOL!

  10. Beautiful review. This sounds very different from the usual YA stuff for sure.

  11. Rachel says:

    Wow, what a great review! I’m putting this on my TBR list now.

  12. stacybuckeye says:

    Okay, I, too, had to pause over a few words, but your review let me know what what they meant. Thanks for using them there big words in a way that let me understand them 🙂
    This book sounds like it struck an authentic chord with you and that is a huge endorsement!

  13. Kim says:

    Sounds very intersting. I’m adding it to my list.

  14. Staci says:

    As always your review blew me away! I will pass this one along to my son.

  15. Jenners says:

    It sounds like a thoughtful and deep running book. Lovely review.

  16. I remember seeing another review of yours earlier this year from a book also by this author. I flagged it to go on my tbr list! This one sounds equally worthy of attention. Thanks for the review.

  17. Pingback: Dark Water by Laura McNeal – Book Review | Linus's Blanket

  18. Laura McNeal says:

    Thank you for taking the time to write such a detailed review. As a former English teacher, I’m doubly moved.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.