Review of “Moonlight Mile” by Dennis Lehane”

Moonlight Mile is written as a sequel to Gone, Baby, Gone, but the author does a great job of filling you in on the background of the story, so you can enjoy this book regardless of whether you read the previous one.

In Gone, Baby, Gone, four-year-old Amanda McCready was kidnapped, and private investigators Patrick Kenzie and Angela Gennaro were hired to find her. She had been living with a mother addicted to drugs, alcohol, and dysfunctional men; those who “kidnapped” her were actually trying to save her. But Kenzie insisted Amanda be returned to her mother, no matter how neglectful she was:

“Rationally, I know damn well I don’t want to live in a world where people can just pluck a child out of a family they deem bad and raise a stolen child as they see fit.”

Kenzie invokes the necessity of laws to keep order in a society, and in particular the role of the Department of Children and Families (DCF): they have “due process” he says; they investigate diligently and only then take kids away. [Oddly, Lehane has Kenzie ignore the failures of DCFs to keep up with caseloads, follow-up on investigations and house visits, etc. In addition, Kenzie seems to forget the corruption he himself has uncovered in the DCF, a breach of the public trust which surely vitiates his argument.]

Kenzie repeatedly is forced by what he finds out as a private investigator to make a choice about what he exposes: on the one hand, he feels obligated to do the job for which he is being paid. He also counts on the alleged “neutrality” of the law to absolve himself of any resulting chaos from his disclosures. But often, situational ethics cry out for a different solution. This was certainly the case with Amanda, and indeed with many of the cases he takes. After years of feeling bad for the havoc he has wreaked, finally, in Moonlight Mile, Kenzie tries to atone for past sins of judgment by bending just a bit to allow others to opt for solutions that may not be so legal, but that are infinitely superior.

There is another consideration that has mellowed Kenzie: he and Gennaro are married now, with a 4-year old daughter they both love dearly, in spite of the fact that parenthood sometimes can be boring and/or drive them crazy.

Thus when Kenzie finds out that Amanda, now sixteen, is missing again, the two of them jump on the case. Little do they expect that this will mean life-threatening encounters with drug dealers, black market baby traders, and the Russian mafia. If they get out of this one, they are determined to retire from this dangerous life.

Evaluation: Some of the dialogue between Patrick and Angela seems too well-scripted, as if we were reading the screenplay for a Nick and Nora Charles movie instead of a real-life interchange between husband and wife. It’s witty, it sparkles, but is it real?

Kenzie’s reasoning about doing the wrong thing for the “right” reason was very off-putting to me. He didn’t hesitate to bend the law when it suited his own purposes, but refused when it was clear he was doing more harm than good by claiming the equivalent of “I was just following orders.” In a better-written book, this might be an interesting character flaw, but I got the impression that Lehane didn’t see the connection, and furthermore, thought he was showing moral integrity instead of moral cowardice.

The resolution struck me as rather unrealistic, although my inner jury is still out on that one. It was quite a shark jump, but seemed a big stretch, nevertheless.

Still, on a positive note, one could say it’s a fast-moving story that seems a bit like an episode of the TV show “Without a Trace.” It would be an okay choice for an airport or other occasion requiring a diverting book.

Rating: 2.8/5

Published by William Morrow, 2010

About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Review of “Moonlight Mile” by Dennis Lehane”

  1. bermudaonion says:

    I’ve heard this isn’t up to Lehane’s usual standards which is disappointing. I do think good dialogue is probably very difficult to write.

  2. Marie says:

    that’s kind of what I expected, LOL 🙂

  3. Staci says:

    I have not read this author but I for sure will not start with this one!!!

  4. Rural View says:

    I have so many books on my list that I really want to read I think I’ll pass on this one. Nice to know when a book isn’t up to par.

  5. Vasilly says:

    Ugh! What a disappointment! A book that has unbelievable dialogue is one of the worst things that an author can do. The reader can no longer believe the characters actions. 😦 I read Lehane’s Mystic River years ago and loved it. I won’t pick this one up. I hope your next read is better.

  6. Julie P. says:

    Probably going to pass on this one. I love the 2.8 rating….

  7. I read this…and think I liked it a bit more than you, but did not love it.
    As to the witty dialogue, everyone I know speaks like that, just like Nora and Nick…really.
    OK, maybe not quite.

  8. I was a bit disappointed in this one for some reason. I was good, but expected better 😦

  9. Belle Wong says:

    This probably isn’t the read for me. I’m not sure why, but I tend not to like books where the protagonist has to always grapple with ethical dilemmas – maybe because there are too many in real life to begin with, and I’m looking for pure entertainment when I read!

  10. zibilee says:

    I think I liked this one a lot more than you did, but I also didn’t really think about the motivations behind Patrick’s decision making processes. You review is certainly more penetrating and delves a lot more deeply into the realities of the situation than mine does, but like you, I found the ending implausible. Thanks for giving me something to think about with this book!

  11. Verity C says:

    Congrats, I have awarded the Seven Facts Award to your blog.

  12. Pingback: 2011: #13 – Moonlight Mile (Dennis Lehane) | Confessions of a Bibliophile

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.