Review of “Black Angels” (Middle Grade Book – 6th Grade and Up) by Linda Beatrice Brown”

During the Civil War, many children were made orphans. For the most part, they had to learn to survive on their own, like the engaging threesome in this inspiring story for adults as well as children.

Luke is an eleven-year-old orphaned slave in North Carolina who steals his master’s gun and runs away to join the Union Army. Along the way, he finds another runaway slave, a nine-year-old girl named Daylily who hid while the rest of her family was killed. Nearby where Daylilly is sleeping, Luke also notices a seven-year old white boy, Caswell. His father is off fighting the Yankees, and his mother has just been killed. At first, Caswell tries to control Luke and Daylilly, because he is white and they are black. But Luke and even Daylilly are so much bigger, and Caswell is so obviously alone and scared, that Luke just laughs at him.

The three of them decide to join forces to get help, and set off for the North. Luke feels responsible for the young ones, and takes charge of their safety and feeding. The small ones are more easily scared, and think about their dead families a lot. When Daylily is afraid, she sings the song her Granny taught her:

“Mama, are there any angels Black like me?
I’ve been as good as any little girl can be.
If I hide my face, do you think they will see?
Mama, are there any angels Black like me?”

Caswell isn’t so sure. He has never seen any pictures of any angels in heaven who aren’t white. Luke reprimands him:

“‘I done already tole you. My mama is there,’ he said quietly, ‘and don’t you never say that again.”

As the days go by, they bond more closely. Luke tells stories at night to calm Caswell’s fears (even though the only stories he knows are the not-very-soothing stories of slave experiences). But Luke is trying to distract Caswell, and it works. Before Luke’s mama died (killed by her owner for insubordination), she told Luke, “Take care of your friends, Luke baby. A friend is a blessing from the Lord in this evil world.” And indeed, after days in the woods, hiding from the armies, enduring an encounter with a mountain lion, scrounging for food, combating fear and cold and illness, they were not only friends, but family. Even Caswell came to feel that way.

For a while, they were able to stay with Betty Strong Foot, a woman half-Indian and half-black, who feeds them and cares for them until it gets too dangerous. She then sends them off to Harpers Ferry, where they split up, with the promise to meet again in ten years in 1874 at Betty’s cabin. Luke gets a job, and keeps at it a long time, but wants to do more with his life. Daylily and Caswell live with a black family until Caswell’s father finds him after the war and takes him back to South Carolina. Caswell is appalled at his father’s racist rants, but doesn’t leave until, as a grown boy, his father insists Caswell join in Ku Klux Klan activities. Daylily begins school, and also takes up teaching.

Would the three really find each other again? Would they feel the same after all the changes they have been through? What effect will the persistence of racism have on them over the years?

Evaluation: This is a lovely book that holds your attention to the end. The characters of the children are written totally true to their ages, in my opinion, which lends the book an unexpected charm. And there’s plenty of suspense. I think readers will find it riveting. Highly recommended for middle grades and up.

Rating: 4/5

Published by G.P. Putnam’s Sons Books for Young Readers, 2009

About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

18 Responses to Review of “Black Angels” (Middle Grade Book – 6th Grade and Up) by Linda Beatrice Brown”

  1. JoAnn says:

    This is the kind of book I would have loved in 5th grade! Wish there was a middle schooler in my life that I could give this to now.

  2. This looks fabulous. Teaching kids in 5th this would be ideal. Not only that, I want to read it. Very nice review!! Thanks.

  3. Barbara says:

    This sounds like an excellent book for a child. How I wish every child could learn these lessons in such a painless way.

  4. Staci says:

    I will have to order this one in the fall!! Sounds like a great read and one that can get some discussions going. My teachers love that! 😀

    • This is such a nice book. There are so many books on the Civil War period, but having one from the perspective of children is just great – it’s a reminder too how differently things appear to kids, and what things scare or perplex them that adults no longer think about.

  5. Alyce says:

    I wonder how many kids were really on their own in that time period. It’s not something I’ve ever really given a lot of thought to. This looks like a good book that would raise important topics.

  6. zibilee says:

    I bet my daughter would love this book, and as I am am in the middle of trying to put some books together for her for the last part of summer, this one sounds very good to me. Thanks for the great and in-depth review!

  7. bermudaonion says:

    This does sound like a marvelous book. I’ll have to see if I can find a copy.

  8. Jenners says:

    I probably would have been all over this back in the day … I was a sucker for orphan stories. It was always the central focus of our play for some strange reason.

    And I love the idea of meeting up in 10 years. That is always a good plot device that keeps you hanging in there.

    Sounds like a real winner!

  9. Margot says:

    I want to read this book so I can see how it ends. I agree with you and Booking Mama. It will be an excellent conversation starter for middle schoolers.

  10. Jenny says:

    I’m not that big on middle-grade historical fiction as a rule, but your review has made me ever so curious to see what happens to the children! What a cool idea for a story.

  11. EL Fay says:

    I would have loved this as a kid. I read a ton of historical fiction when I was little and was hugely interested in the Civil War.

  12. Amanda says:

    My youngest son is very, very interested in the Civil War. He’s too young for this book now (he’s 6, reading at about 3rd grade level) but in a few years I think this is one he’ll like a lot.

  13. Julie P. says:

    I actually passed my copy on to my daughter’s fourth grade teacher because I really felt this book lends itself to the classroom! Thanks for sharing!

  14. Andrea says:

    Thank you for the review. I will be picking up a copy for your niece!

  15. Cookie White says:

    I delighted to find this information on the Black Angel song. My gradmother used to sing it but we never knew its origin. Thanks!

  16. Dorothy Hinds says:

    Is the song ” Are there any angels Black like me ?” an actual song ? It brought tears to my eyes. I’d love to know if there are more verses.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.