Women’s History Month – Review of the Children’s Book “Catching the Moon: The Story of A Young Girl’s Baseball Dream” by Crystal Hubbard and illustrated by Randy DuBurke

Who do you think took Hank Aaron’s place on the Negro League Indianapolis Clowns when Aaron moved to the Major Leagues? It was none other than a female: thirty-two year old Toni Stone (born Marcenia Lyle).

She was the first female member of an (otherwise) all-male professional baseball team. She began her career as a pitcher with the Twin Cities Colored Giants, and from there moved on to semiprofessional and minor league Negro teams prior to joining the Indianapolis team.

And before that, she was a little girl with a big dream. This charming book with wonderful illustrations tells the story of how Marcenia, as a very young girl, had no other wish but to play baseball. Her father was opposed: he thought she should be like other girls:

“‘She’ll be what every other girl in this neighborhood will be,’ Papa grumbled. ‘A teacher, a nurse, or – ‘

‘A maid,’ Mama said softly.”

Marcenia got her big chance when Gabby Street, manager for the St. Louis Cardinals, came by her playground looking for kids for his baseball camp. He told Marcenia he could only take boys, but she was so good he gave in and even bought her a pair of cleats:

“Marcenia felt as proud and happy as if she had reached right up in the sky and caught the moon in her glove. She was on her way to becoming a real baseball player. She would make her dream come true.”

Marcenia changed her name when she grew up so that it would sound less cutesy (and more androgenous). As Toni Stone, her most memorable baseball moment came when she played against the legendary Satchel Paige in 1953:

“He was so good,’ she remembered, ‘that he’d ask batters where they wanted it, just so they’d have a chance. He’d ask, ‘You want it high? You want it low? You want it right in the middle? Just say.’ People still couldn’t get a hit against him. So I get up there and he says, ‘Hey, T, how do you like it?’ And I said, ‘It doesn’t matter, just don’t hurt me.’ When he wound up–he had these big old feet–all you could see was his shoe. I stood there shaking, but I got a hit. Right out over second base. Happiest moment in my life.”

Toni Stone (center) with the Creoles, for whom she played 1949-1952.

In 1985 Stone was inducted into the Women’s Sports Foundation’s International Women’s Sports Hall of Fame. In 1990 she was also inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame where she is a part of two separate exhibits including “Women in Baseball” and “Negro League Baseball”. In 1993 Stone was also inducted into the Women’s Sports Hall of Fame as well as the Sudafed International Women’s Sports Hall of Fame.

Evaluation: This inspiring, heartwarming book for children has beautiful illustrations by Randy DuBurke and a wonderful message, especially for young girls who want to go beyond the boundaries of what is expected of them.

Rating: 4.8/5

Published by Lee & Low Books, 2005

Note: You can read an interview with author Crystal Hubbard here in which she talks about what inspired her to write about trailblazers in her picture books.


About rhapsodyinbooks

We're into reading, politics, and intellectual exchanges.
This entry was posted in Book Review, Sports, Women's History Month and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Women’s History Month – Review of the Children’s Book “Catching the Moon: The Story of A Young Girl’s Baseball Dream” by Crystal Hubbard and illustrated by Randy DuBurke

  1. JoAnn says:

    My daughter, the budding sports journalist, would have loved this. On second thought, she’d still probably love it! I remember her doing a paper in high school on the first All-American Girls Professional Baseball League. She’s the sports editor for her college paper now.

  2. ds says:

    That is some story! Love how all she could see of Satchel Paige when he pitched was his foot. That’s the kind of detail that makes books like this so interesting for kids–and adults. Thanks so much for your excellent presentation.

  3. Aarti says:

    I love the way you integrate history into your book reviews. It makes me feel smarter just for reading them 🙂 What a great children’s book!

  4. ds,

    Actually the Satchel Paige story is not part of the book, but I loved it, so added it as “background” info! :–)

  5. Julie P. says:

    Sounds like a wonderful book that needs to be shared in our schools! The illustrations are gorgeous!

  6. Nymeth says:

    I’ve never had much of an interest in baseball (we’re all about soccer here), but I’m sold anyway. It sounds like it’s about so much more anyway.

  7. Alyce says:

    That is amazing! I hadn’t ever heard of her before, but it seems like her story would be a true inspiration to girl athletes.

  8. this one is awesome!! I love the illustrations along with the actual pictures. I’m going to look at a copy at B&N to see if it’s too young for my library. But even so, I will recommend it to the elementary librarian!!

  9. softdrink says:

    I think that’s the coolest thing I’ve learned this week! I had no idea women had ever played professional baseball with men.

  10. Toni Gomez says:

    Fantastic Review. The book sounds so inspirational. I have to agree…the illustrations are magnificent.

  11. Margot says:

    I like this one. I’m not a baseball person so I hadn’t heard of her. I love stories about people who make breakthroughs like this.

  12. Oh man, is it bad that pretty much all I know about women’s softball/baseball comes from watching A League of Her Own? (I do love that movie though).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.