Review of “Talulla Rising” by Glen Duncan

Note: There are necessarily spoilers for Book One in this series, The Last Werewolf, but none for this book, the sequel.

Talulla is a female werewolf who survived the murder of her werewolf lover Jake, killed by WOCOP, an anti-supernatural organization. WOCOP is still in the picture, but under new leadership and more outrageous than ever. The operatives of WOCOP seemed almost rational in Book One; in Book Two, the members are too deranged to be believable.

Talulla was left with a surprise by Jake – she is pregnant. Quite soon into the story, she bears twins, and one of them is kidnapped by vampires who believe that werewolf blood will allow them to walk in the light. [The belief that walking in the sun will be enabled by ingesting the blood of another non-human species is now a pretty common trope in vampire fiction. “True Blood” watchers, for example, know that in the Charlaine Harris-inspired fantasy world, vampires think faery blood will accomplish this goal.]

For the rest of the story, Talulla is trying to get her first child back; worrying about not eating the second one; and you know – the usual motherhood concerns. She is, moreover, always in the thrall of werewolf animal lust – not just during the full moon, but all the time. [Unfamiliar with the concept of TMI, she never misses a chance to share her fantasies with the readers.] But all this sex-drive business makes her feel guilty; lust and motherhood are not supposed to go together. [Someone has been soaking up too much of that virgin/whore propaganda!]

If all of this sounds silly or offensive, it comes out less so in the hands of Glen Duncan, but only just.

Discussion: I was highly impressed with the Duncan’s literary representation of genre fiction in The Last Werewolf (see my review, here). His fleshing out of the werewolf metaphor, interesting take on existential ennui, clever phrase construction, and numerous literary allusions elevated that first effort, in my mind, to something special.

This second book disappointed me, however. This time, many of the literary and cultural allusions seemed gratuitous or even silly. The references to the beastliness of the werewolf sounded more like porn than commentary on our animal natures. And the plot struck me as closer to that of a late-late-Saturday night “C” movie than to the sophisticated tale Duncan wove in Book One. The repeated scenes of putative calm interrupted by attacks from armed predators lacked only commercial breaks between onslaughts. In fact, I almost didn’t finish it (but as it happened, I was on the road and out of books!).

Evaluation: I would still recommend Book One (The Last Werewolf), but wouldn’t necessary endorse Book Two, Talulla Rising.

Rating: 1.5/5

Published by Alfred A. Knopf, a division of Random House, 2012

About these ads

10 Responses

  1. See, the only thing that got me through the first book was the incredibly HOT voice of Robin Sachs. If not for that, I would have quit listening right around disc 2. I agree he has a clever turn of phrase, excellent writing, but these creatures inspired no investment in me. And I know you loved that first book, so if you feel like this about book 2, no way I am going there.

  2. You lost me at werewolf. I give you a lot of credit for giving this book a try.

  3. I don’t know if I will read this one. The first pushed the envelope, but it was thrilling and full of a feral grace that I enjoyed. I knew there would be a second, but now that I’ve heard your opinion, I think I will pass. Thanks for the candor, my friend. It’s much appreciated.

  4. YIKES. I am not all about starting a series that falls so completely off a cliff – I think I’ll give the whole thing a miss.

  5. Ok. I’ve been wondering about this series. I think I’ll just let it go. I like paranormal but I have enough series going.

  6. no…no…not for me…

  7. Jlli, I definitely will NOT read this – sounds like a rip off of Fifty Shades territory – do authors think we need lust to keep us interested in a story? I prefer character myself.

  8. I don’t think this series is for me. I tried the first book and could not get past 20 pages. I don’t even think I got passed 15 and then I tried it on audio which didn’t help.

  9. Wow! This goes to show how hard it is to do a second book well.

  10. 1.5 rating? Wow…and sad. That’s too bad that book two just didn’t deliver! :(

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 359 other followers

%d bloggers like this: